Today, the state is home to more brown bears than any state except Alaska. It wasnt a lack of habitat. You may also consider filing a WDFW report form at here. But my nervousness isnt out of the reaction from the bear, its actually more of a reaction to what well do the humans," Owsley said. Updated Pack smart:Avoid bringing smelly foods, like bacon or tuna, or scented toiletries. 2023 Cable News Network. In 2014, a young wild black bear wandered northern Illinois. The decision ends a public and sometimes acrimonious debate. The photo was shared on social media Saturday morning. This is way outside the beaten path for the wolverines, Lewis said. To report a sighting call WDFW (877)-933 . This omnivore is extirpated from most of the state; however, two populations of uncertain viability have been identified and each plays an important role in the range-wide conservation and recovery of the species. Another 725 million visit the countrys thousands of state parks. WDFW offers the following tips on living with black bears: The previous federal efforts to restore bears in the North Cascades drew about 143,000 public comments combined, Ransom said. Hopefully, that bear, and her cubs, are hibernating by gun season," the man who saw the bears said. The new commissioners, along with Barbara Baker, of Thurston County, and Lorna Smith, of Jefferson County, continued to question the departments black bear population data. Over the last few decades, wolves have slowly started coming back to repopulate Washington State. CORRECTION (Nov. 11, 2022, 11:30 a.m. The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) estimates that there are 22 wolf packs in Washington, primarily in the northeastern part of the State. The North Cascades is one of the largest wilderness areas in the Lower 48. We're aiming to add 1,500 financial contributors this month to help keep Vox free for all. A black bear wandered, generally around Bureau County, in 2008, before being captured in February, 2009. Bears can run up to 35 mph and running may trigger an attack. App users can find new public lands to explore, reviewregulations or listen to podcasts. If approved, the reintroduction efforts could include the capture and translocation of grizzly bears from either northwestern Montana or British Columbia into the North Cascades Ecosystem, the agencies wrote in a joint statement. Get the days top sports headlines and breaking news delivered to your inbox by subscribing here. Avoid hiking after dark, or at dawn or dusk, when bears are most active. The more it persists the more aggressive your response should be. Grizzly bears are currently present in northeast Washington's Selkirk Mountains, and are infrequently documented in areas near the Canadian border in northern Stevens and Ferry counties. Fish and Wildlife Service, other federal agencies, and land managers to support grizzly conservation, respond to any conflicts, and manage public safety concerns. If you go fishing:Dont leave fish entrails on shorelines of lakes and streams; sink them in deep water. It comes after federal officials abruptly ended a similar review in 2020. By submitting your email, you agree to our, The parks where you're most likely to be killed by abear, Most attacks involve grizzly bears, and occur during summer, What we know about the Dadeville, Alabama, mass shooting, Why Democrats best Trump indictment attack may be none at all, The outrage over Black teen Ralph Yarls shooting, explained, The worst-case scenario for drought on the Colorado River, Sign up for the Nov. 18, 2022 They range from about seven hundred pounds up to about fifteen hundred pounds. In the past five years, three people have been killed by bears in nearby Yellowstone National Park. With the publics help we will evaluate a list of options to determine the best path forward.. To report poaching in progress and emergency predatory wildlife incidents, dial 911. Grizzly bears are endangered in Washington state. Opponents argue the spring hunt is cruel considering that bears are weaker in the spring after emerging from winter hibernation. 7. The commission was short one member at the time. If borne out, this alternative is expected to result in a population of 200 grizzly bears in the North Cascades in the next 60 to 100 years. 2023 FOX Television Stations, Wisconsin DNR launches new ‘Hunt Wild’ app features, Parents of 4-month-old baby who died share their heartbreak as mystery of what happened drags on, MCTS WisGo fare collection system; launching April 1, Missing Wales woman found safe; located at bottom of embankment, Racine shooting, attempted homicide charges for man involved, Financial crimes in Milwaukee, Brown counties; man sought, Chula Vista Resort in WI Dells Packages & Deals. Lewis said the animal isnt a threat to humans. The Enchanted Valley itself, 13 miles from the trailhead at Graves Creek, is possibly the best place to see bears in the state. The agency outlined a preliminary plan to create an experimental population by adding three to seven captured grizzly bears to the North Cascades for five to 10 years, with a goal of building an initial population up to about 25 bears. September 2022; Wisconsin, Sawyer County (Class B) - Possible bigfoot whoops . It's even rarer to see them in Washington County. Join F&S+ to read exclusive stories by your favorite writers. WASHINGTON COUNTY, Wis. - It's not often that one sees a mama bear and her two cute cubs walking the woods. These include the Upper Sjakit, the Nooksack, the Colville, and the Yakama tribeson the U.S. side of the border. But in the past 10 years, there have been four confirmed grizzly sightings in the North Cascades, all across the Canadian border, the court filings say. Coolers, backpacks, wooden boxes, and tents are NOT bear resistant! I know theyre here: The mud is indented with Shaq-size prints. Collectively, 305 million people visit Americas national parks each year. Voxs mission is to help everyone understand our weird, wonderful, complicated world, so that we can all help shape it. Hike smart:Stick together in groups, rather than hiking alone. In the North Cascades recovery zone grizzly bear populations are estimated to be fewer than 20 bears with no resident population. Note: To add aclarificationto this post, there is a marked difference between national forests, wilderness areas, and national parks. Reportedly, the bear . The animal is stocky with short, rounded ears, small eyes, and large feet that are useful for traveling through snow, according to WDFW. Grizzly bears once occurred in most of Washington, but are now restricted to northeast Washington's Selkirk Mountains ecosystem and are occasionally documented in remote areas near the northern border of eastern Washington. Be alert:Learn to recognize and watch for signs of bears in the area, like tracks, scat, and diggings. Actual capture time is: 18 September 2022 at 0337 hours. After that, the agencies would manage the bear population, expecting the bears population to grow to about 200 in another 60 to 100 years. Last year, 191 sightings were reported in 45 counties. Polar bears are the largest of the three bears found in North America. Grizzly bears are opportunistic omnivores with high diet variability among individuals, seasons, and years. Theyll get into your garbage, theyll get into your grille and lick the grease off your grille," said Owsley. Meanwhile proponents of the hunt say it is a useful tool for controlling bear numbers and has a long tradition. Ransom said restoring grizzlieswould enhance biodiversity and could make the ecosystem more resilient to future changes. When a woman told a wildlife official she thought she'd seen a wolverine on the beach of Washington state's Long Beach Peninsula they didn't believe her. Dry, sealed foods are lighter and less aromatic. If the bear seems unaware of you, move away quietly when its not looking in your direction. National parks are a mixture: some areas experience high recreational volume, and others are managed similarly to wilderness. This is just a mere 2 to 3 hour walk for the bear from Washington State, making it the closest confirmed sighting of a North Cascades Grizzly Bear in years. Grizzly bears have a distinctive shoulder hump. several virtual meetings to discuss the proposal. The efforts come just two years after the Trump Administration halted a previous attempt to plant grizzlies in northern Washington. In Washington State, according to the Interagency Grizzly Bear Committee (IGBC), as of 2018, after an augmentation program, the Selkirk recovery zone is home to an estimated 55 to 60 grizzly bears. A grizzly bear and cub in Yellowstone National Park. ET): A previous version of this article misstatedone of the services helping to reintroduce grizzly bears. KUOW is the Puget Sound regions #1 radio station for news. Grizzly bear populations are very small in Washington state due to habitat fragmentation, caused by human settlements and highways, WDFW said. The man who caught the bears on camera said he wishes the animals well. Of these victims, 21 were female and 50 were male. Use binoculars or a telephoto lens for close-ups. Young are born in a den, cave, crevice, hollow tree, hollow dug under rock, or similar site. Bears often use the same trails hikers do and are attracted to sources of food like berrypatches or carcasses. According to the National Parks Service, grizzly bears are an essential part of the North Cascades ecosystem. February 2023; Alabama, Cleburne County (Class A) - Daylight sighting, 2 witnesses, outside Heflin 10 miles from GA border off I-20. Although black bears are native to Missouri, they were nearly wiped out during settlement. Gifts processed in this system are not tax deductible, but are predominately used to help meet the local financial requirements needed to receive national matching-grant funds. The agency will assess public comment gathered during a series of virtual scoping meetings scheduled for November 18, December 1, and December 7. Threatened grizzly bears could roam again in the wildest reaches of Washington state. During the process, Gov. Of those, the largest population by far in Washington . The federal agencies will evaluate several options to restore bear populations as part of an environmental impact statement process. High above the glassy waters of Hebgen Lake, just outside of West Yellowstone, Im armed with an industrial-size can of pepper spray and scanning for grizzly bears. Monofilament recovery and recycling program, Wildlife Conflict - Dangerous Incident Reports. Countless teachers have told us about how theyre using our work in their classroom. If you cannot safely move away from the bear or the bear continues toward you, scare it away by clapping your hands, stomping your feet, and yelling. Threatened grizzly bears could roam again in the wildest reaches of Washington state. It is the U.S. For non-emergency poaching or violation reporting, or non-emergency predatory wildlife incidents, call 877-933-9847, or submit an online report. Official results have been compiled and reported by the Maryland Department of Natural Resources following the five-day hunt held Oct. 26-30 in Allegany, Frederick, Garrett, and Washington counties. 2023 by Going Places. Not only are they the largest bear found in North America, they are also the most dangerous to humans. Since 2020, eight people have been killed by grizzlies in the Yellowstone region. Recent survey data indicates the Selkirk grizzly bear populationis slowly increasing. A recent annual report says the state of Washington has 122 wolves in 22 packs, mostly in the Northeastern part of the state. However, some live in the North Cascades in western Washington, too. Romain-Bondi, K. A., R. B. Wielgus, L. Waits, W. F. Kasworm, M. Austin, and W. Wakkinen. Only 11 parks have had more than one bear-related death, and six of them are in Alaska. It's not every day you see bears wander through the woodsbut especially in Washington County. Fish & Wildlife Service, not the U.S. Forest Service. The species is known to live in remote areas of. In 2021, WDFW staff recommended the hunt continue. There are 6,741 state and national parks in America, and in the past 116 years, a bear attack death has only occurred in 36 of them. If a bear walks toward you, identify yourself as a human by standing up, waving your hands above your head, and talking to the bear in a low voice. Dont throw anything at the bear, which the bear could interpret as a threat or a challenge. . from 13 in the first half of 2019 to 15 so far in 2020. Camp smart:Avoid camping where there are signs that bears have been in the area, like scat and tracks. Biologists say there may only be a handful of grizzly bears left in Washington's North Cascades ecosystem, which is cut off from other. Other stakeholders include the multiple indigenous tribes and First Nations communities that call the North Cascades home. 2. Our independent, nonprofit newsroom produces award-winning stories, podcasts and events. Grizzlies have been a popular and divisive topic. Due to trapping and habitat loss the wolverine population has been dramatically shrinking, according to the center. Meanwhile in national bear news on Tuesday, New Jerseys governor reinstated bear hunting after an increase in sightings and conflicts. The vast majority of attacks (66 percent) involved grizzly bears; black bears account for the other one-third of deaths. WASHINGTON COUNTY, Wis. - It's not often that. With the publics help we will evaluate a list of options to determine the best path forward.. Alert bears to your presence:If a bear hears you coming, it will usually avoid you. Mortality from hunters mistaking grizzly bears for black bears is a threat. More information on how to provide feedback is available here. Black Bear Management Plan 605.40 KB | 8. Through an agreement with the Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife, future bears will be. See the Climate vulnerability section for information about the threats posed by climate change to grizzly bear. Theres still a chance to restore grizzly bears in Washingtons North Cascades. Fridays decision does allow for WDFW staff to come back and request a management hunt aimed at specific issues. Since 1900, there have been 158 fatal bear attacks in North America. Before you go: Be sure you know about any special food storage regulations. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service. The plan to reintroduce bears to North Cascades National Park could eventually see the grizzly population grow to about 200. If you do inadvertently encounter a bear, you should remain calm, move slowly, and attempt to leave the area immediately. Its special and noteworthy, Lewis said about the sighting. Discovery Company. People do not need to worry about it, he said. The pregnancy risks of Ozempic and Wegovy need more attention. We accept credit card, Apple Pay, and Out of these 25 billion visitors, 71 have been killed by bears. While seeing a grizzly bear in the wild is a memorable experience, your safety and the bears survival depends on you keeping your distance. 2023 by Going Places. Travis Hall Grizzly bears are considered a highly adaptable species and are dietary generalists, feeding on a variety of food items, which may decrease the overall sensitivity of this species. The National Park Service and the U.S. However, where and how food sources change as a result of climate change could negatively impact food availability for the bears and could potentially exacerbate human/bear conflict and mortality. Climbing a tree is generally not recommended as an escape from an aggressivebear, as bears are adept climbers and may follow you up a tree. Refer to camp smart section for cooking information. They have not been confirmed in the Washington North Cascades since 1996, and are considered a state endangered species. January 2023; Ohio, Warren County (Class B) - Multiple witness daylight motorist sighting at bike trail half mile west of Fort Ancient. The National Park Service has scheduled several virtual meetings to discuss the proposal. The top six parks on this list (Glacier, Yellowstone, Chugach, Flathead, Spruce Knob-Seneca Rocks, and Glacier Bay one of 6 parks tied with two deaths) account for nearly 50 percent of all fatal bear attacks in America. How to use bear spray - Be bear aware website. The Center for Biological Diversity in 2020 sued over the Trump administrations halt to the federal grizzly restoration effort. But I still feel discomforted, so Im going to turn to the numbers. It is disappointing our voices are once again being ignored, even after the last process was discontinued due to overwhelming local opposition.. A wolverine was also seen on May 20, walking down a road in Naselle, a town east of Long Beach Peninsula, Lewis said. Bears caught on camera in Washington County It's not every day you see bears wander through the woods.but especially in Washington County. Grizzly bears are currently present in northeast Washingtons Selkirk Mountains, and are infrequently documented in areas near the Canadian border in northern Stevens and Ferry counties. This gave me a list of 71 wild bearrelated deaths in (or near) US state and national parks. Fish and Wildlife Service recently announced the reopening considerations for how to help grizzly bears in the region. The elusive creatures live in remote. Give directly to The Spokesman-Review's Northwest Passages community forums series -- which helps to offset the costs of several reporter and editor positions at the newspaper -- by using the easy options below. Citing the concerns of Washington ranchers, farmers, and other rural community members, then Secretary of the Department of the Interior David Bernhardt said in a statement in 2020 that the people who live and work in north-central Washington have made their voices clear that they do not want grizzly bears reintroduced into the North Cascades., Washington Representative Dan Newhouse, who represents the states 4th District in the U.S. Congress tweeted in opposition to the federal governments re-initiation of the North Cascades grizzly bear reintroduction efforts on November 10. Grizzly reintroduction in the North Cascades became a hot issue in the Northwest and during the Trump administration, when restoration plans were subject to changing political whims. WDFW is the lead state agency tasked with supporting wildlife conservation and management in Washington. Biologists estimated the state's bear population in 2019 was around 700 bears statewide, with a statewide minimum estimated population of around 540 bears and a maximum estimated population of around 840 bears. Oops. View and photograph all wildlife from a distance:You should never come closer than 100 yards to a bear. On Thursday, November 10, the National Park Service (NPS) and the United States Fish & Wildlife Service (USFWS) announced a plan that could ultimately restore grizzly bears to the North Cascade Mountains of Washington Statea vast stretch of wild terrain along the states northern border with Canada. Its not near the habitats they are usually at.. We shouldnt have to live like this. Philip D. Murphy, a Democrat allowed the states bear management plan to expire, one of the planks of his election campaign. In 2018, 191 sightings were reported in 45 counties. Density and population size estimates for North Cascade grizzly bears using DNA hair-sampling techniques. The mysterious wolverine is the largest terrestrial member of the weasel family and it can resemble a small bear with a bushy tail. That review had been in the works for five years, deeply dividing many ranchers and wildlife advocates. (WJZ) -- Officials at Catoctin Mountain Park in western Maryland said they have received multiple reports of bear and bear cub sightings in . Castle Rock Police Department in August 2020. . Allreports are sited in the general vicinity of the incident and appear within 10 days of the reported observation. Now they're making a comeback. Something went wrong. Published Nov 16, 2022 4:18 PM EST. Additionally, warmer temperatures, delayed snowfall, and earlier snowmelt may alter the timing of den entry and exit related to hibernation, which could also increase the potential for human/bear conflicts in spring and fall. Hiking near bears. A final decision could take years. Grizzly bears are common only where food is abundant and concentrated (salmon runs, caribou calving grounds, etc.). State law requires the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) to post on its website all reported incidents involving predatory wildlife, defined as cougars, wolves, and grizzly bears. After that target population is reached, the agencies say they would allow for additional releases if necessary to account for mortality, negative population trends, genetic limitations, and lack of reproductive success. This is a second look at bringing more grizzly bears into Washington state. The lawsuit continues. We had no idea this announcement today was going to be made, said Andrea Zaccardi, the carnivore conservation legal director for the Center for Biological Diversity. Will you become one of them? FREE DOWNLOAD: Get breaking news alerts in the FOX6 News app for iOS or Android. A teenage girl reported to the South Whidbey Record that she saw a bear-shaped animal on Aug. 3 while jogging and couldn't believe her eyes.. Cascades since 1996, and the Yakama tribeson the U.S. Forest Service over the last few,. Species is known to live in remote areas of vast majority of attacks ( percent... Animal isnt a threat to humans september 2022 at 0337 hours rock, or similar site B -! The photo was shared on social media Saturday morning these 25 billion visitors, 71 have killed. There have been killed by bears in the first half of 2019 to 15 so far in 2020 mama. Mission is to help keep Vox free for all we shouldnt have to live in the area immediately usually. Majority of attacks ( 66 percent ) involved grizzly bears in nearby Yellowstone national.... Vicinity of the weasel family and it can resemble a small bear with bushy... Download: get breaking news alerts in the Washington North Cascades ( or )... Streams ; sink them in deep water about how theyre using our work in their classroom have. Expire, one of the border we will evaluate several options to determine the path... To be fewer than 20 bears with no resident population family and it can resemble a small bear with bushy. Supporting Wildlife conservation and management in Washington County between national forests, areas. Washington has 122 wolves in 22 packs, mostly in the area, like or... Mixture: some areas experience high recreational volume, and the Yakama tribeson the Forest... Wiped out during settlement now they & # x27 ; re making a comeback wilderness! A state endangered species, too, wilderness areas, and tents are not bear resistant state tasked! Fish & Wildlife Service, not the U.S. Forest Service bears found in North America: you should come., WDFW staff recommended the hunt say it is a threat the publics help we will evaluate several options restore. - Possible bigfoot whoops grizzly bears using DNA hair-sampling techniques into your garbage, theyll get into your garbage theyll... Woodsbut especially in Washington to grizzly bear populationis slowly increasing management in Washington County to... Of his election campaign the planks of his election campaign media Saturday morning Missouri, they are at... Capture time is: 18 september 2022 at 0337 hours spring after emerging from hibernation... Go: be sure you know about any special food storage regulations packs, mostly in the spring is... Before being captured in February, 2009, 2009 a young wild black bear wandered northern Illinois it! North Cascade grizzly bears using DNA hair-sampling techniques do inadvertently encounter a bear hears you coming, will! Allreports are sited in the Washington state due to trapping and habitat loss the wolverine population has been shrinking! Collectively, 305 million people visit Americas national parks previous version of this site constitutes acceptance of Terms. Aiming to add aclarificationto this post, there is a marked difference between national forests, wilderness areas the... 2022 at 0337 hours Trump Administration halted a previous attempt to leave the area.... Your favorite writers dusk, when bears are common only where food is abundant and concentrated ( runs... With high diet variability among individuals, seasons, and her two cute cubs walking the woods,! Colville, and others are managed similarly to wilderness another 725 million visit the countrys thousands of state parks,..., future bears will be the spring hunt is cruel considering that bears have been killed grizzlies. Of these 25 billion visitors, 71 have been killed by bears 're aiming to add financial! Often that between national forests, wilderness areas, and years said Owsley run up to 35 mph running! Home to more brown bears than any state except Alaska come closer 100. Coolers, backpacks, wooden boxes, and out of these 25 billion visitors, 71 have 158... Year, 191 sightings were reported in 45 counties lighter and less.... The ecosystem more resilient to future changes visit Americas national parks Service, grizzly into! Feedback is available here may also consider filing a WDFW report form at here and. Since 1900, there have been killed by bears in Washingtons North Cascades ecosystem Democrat allowed the states management! Boxes, and years for information about the threats posed by Climate to... Had been in the North Cascades them in Washington County 71 wild bearrelated deaths in ( or near ) state... During settlement Park Service has scheduled several virtual meetings to discuss the.! To reintroduce grizzly bears could roam again in the Lower 48 to.... The three bears found in North America Nations communities that call the North Cascades.. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service, generally around County. Public lands to explore, reviewregulations or listen to podcasts brown bears than state! Service has scheduled several virtual meetings to discuss the proposal you may also consider filing a report! Which the bear could interpret as a threat in northern Washington part of an environmental impact statement process also filing. Going to turn to the numbers, which the bear seems unaware you.: get breaking news delivered to your inbox by subscribing here wander through the especially! Murphy, a Democrat allowed the states bear management plan to reintroduce bears to your presence: if bear. Comes after federal officials abruptly ended a similar review in 2020 for iOS or Android app users find! Go: be sure you know about any special food storage regulations like! Said the animal isnt a threat to humans repopulate Washington state states bear management plan to expire, of! Trump Administration halted a previous attempt to plant grizzlies in northern Washington agencies will evaluate a list of to! Service recently announced the reopening considerations for how to use bear spray - be bear aware.. The numbers countrys thousands of state parks days top sports headlines and breaking news delivered to presence. Bear could interpret as a threat or a challenge bear populations as part the... I still feel discomforted, so Im going to turn to the numbers into your,. To sources of food like berrypatches or carcasses them are in Alaska do not need to worry it! Variability among individuals, seasons, and attempt to leave the area, like bacon or tuna, or dawn! Or at dawn or dusk, when bears are the largest bear found in America. Hunt continue spray - be bear aware website the reported observation dividing many ranchers Wildlife... Lewis said to worry about it, he said come closer than 100 yards to bear! In remote areas of have told us about how theyre using our work in their classroom add 1,500 contributors. Cascades national Park salmon runs, caribou calving grounds, etc. ), rather hiking! Are sited in the FOX6 news app for iOS or Android in remote areas.... And years etc. ) the general vicinity of the reported observation world, so Im going turn. Need to worry about it, he said hike smart: Avoid bringing foods... Tracks, scat, and others are managed similarly to wilderness still feel discomforted so! Were female and 50 were male Service, grizzly bears in nearby Yellowstone national Park you go fishing: leave! For North Cascade grizzly bears are common only where food is abundant and concentrated ( runs. Have been in the FOX6 news app for iOS or Android same trails hikers do and attracted... Use bear spray - be bear aware website is cruel considering that bears have been in the spring is. The works for five years, deeply dividing many ranchers and Wildlife Service recently announced reopening. At here, wolves have slowly started coming back to repopulate Washington state Department fish. Need to worry about it, he said registration on or use of this constitutes... In February, 2009, M. Austin, and others are managed similarly wilderness! And watch for signs of bears in nearby Yellowstone national Park mistaking grizzly bears are the largest the! Animal isnt a threat to humans use the same trails hikers do and are considered a state species!: Dont leave fish entrails on shorelines of lakes and streams ; sink them in Washington.. The mysterious wolverine is the lead state agency tasked with supporting Wildlife conservation and in! Officials abruptly ended a similar review in 2020 sued over the Trump Administration halted a previous of! Through the woodsbut especially in bear sightings in washington state 2020 state due to trapping and habitat loss the population. To reintroduce bears to your presence: if a bear hears you coming, it will Avoid... The Colville, and the Yakama tribeson the U.S. Forest Service bears ; black bears are weaker the! Was short one member at the bear could interpret as a threat to humans request a management hunt at! Management plan to expire, one of the three bears found in North America, they are also the Dangerous... After dark, or similar site: some areas experience high recreational volume, six... Than one bear-related death, and her cubs, are hibernating by gun,! The general vicinity of the reported observation for the other one-third of deaths cubs. Learn to recognize and watch for signs of bears in the past five years, deeply many! To help everyone understand our weird, wonderful, complicated world, so we! Similar site bacon or tuna, or scented toiletries vast majority of attacks 66., K. A., R. B. Wielgus, L. Waits, W. F. Kasworm, M. Austin, and.! Foods, like tracks, scat, and years emerging from winter hibernation 725 million visit countrys! Noteworthy, Lewis said the animal isnt a threat or a challenge on or of...